«The Great Turning Point»: collectivisation and Holodomor in Ukraine in the dimension of relations between the government and the peasantry

Main Article Content

Oleksandr Nikiliev

Abstract

The purpose of the study is to analyze the reasons for the communist authorities’ brutal implementation of the collectivization
and dispossession policy and its terrible demographic and humanitarian consequences in Ukraine.
Scientific novelty: a set of theoretical and practical factors is highlighted that determined the authorities’ anti-human
policy towards the Ukrainian peasantry in the late 1920s and early 1930s and led to profound socio-economic and humanitarian
changes. The forms and methods of implementing collectivization in the republic are considered. The attitude of the peasants
to collectivization is highlighted, a wide range of passive and active forms of their peaceful and armed struggle against the
authorities’ intentions to change their socio-economic status is considered. The reasons for the defeat of the peasantry are analyzed.
They lie in the plane of theoretical provisions that guided the Bolshevik Party in its relations with the peasantry. These
provisions were formulated by the founders of Marxism, who defined the peasantry as a reactionary class that has no future and
proposed involving its economic and human potential in building a new system. Lenin and his associates took these dogmas as
a basis and consolidated them in the minds of the members of their party. Based on the theoretical provisions of Marxism about
the hostility of the peasantry to the interests of the working class and the experience of the Civil war and Ukrainian liberation
struggles, in which entire peasant armies participated, the Bolshevik government, upon establishing its regime in the republic,
punished with increased cruelty any manifestations of peasant discontent, considering them a threat to its existence. On a
significant scale, it removed from the peasant environment its most charismatic element, capable of organizing resistance, and
weapons. In this way, it deprived it of the proper organizational, human, and armed potential, and the willpower to organize a
significant struggle.
Conclusion. When the policy of forced collectivization of the Ukrainian countryside began to be implemented, it, despite
mass demonstrations and the use of a wide range of forms and methods of resistance, was no longer able to resist it. As a result, a serious socio-economic breakdown occurred. Its consequences: the loss of a self-sufficient peasant-owner, a bearer of experience in agricultural production and the spiritual culture of the nation, the closure of many aspects of the production, social, and cultural life of the village to bureaucratic structures controlled by the state and the communist party, the loss of a free peasant, the formation of a slave-laborer. The “Great Breakthrough” was programmed at the very beginning of the formation of the communist doctrine.

Article Details

How to Cite
Nikiliev, O. (2025). «The Great Turning Point»: collectivisation and Holodomor in Ukraine in the dimension of relations between the government and the peasantry. Ukrainian Peasant, (36). https://doi.org/10.31651/2413-8142-2025-36-Nikiliev
Section
The Holodomor 1932 – 1932
Author Biography

Oleksandr Nikiliev, The Oles‵` Honchar Dnipros՚k national university

Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor, The Oles‵` Honchar Dnipros՚k national university, Dnipro, Ukraine
ОRCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9918-3999
e-mail: O_Nikilev@i.ua

References

Beznosov, O. (2001). Mennonity yuha Ukrayny v hody «velykoho pereloma». (1928–1933 hh.).[ Mennonites of the south of

Ukraine in the years of the «great turning point» (1928–1933)⁆. Voprosy hermanskoi іstorіі. [Questions of German history ⁆, 75–88. [in

Ukrainian].

Danylenko, V. (2009). Antyradianske povstannia selian v Ukraini naperedodni holodomoru [Anti-Soviet peasant uprising in

Ukraine on the eve of the Holodomor ⁆. Pavlohradske povstannia 1930 r.: Dokumenty i materialy [Pavlohrad Uprising of 1930: Documents

and Materials⁆. Kyiv: Ukrainskyi pysmennyk, 13–27. [in Ukrainian].

Danylenko, V., Kasianov, H. & Kulchytskyi, S. (1991). Stalinizm na Ukraini. 20–30-ti roky. [Stalinism in Ukraine.

s–1930s⁆. Kyiv: Lybid. [in Ukrainian].

Derzhavnyi arkhiv Dnipropetrovskoi oblasti.

Enhels, F. Pryntsypy kommunizmu [The principles of communism⁆. Marks K. & Enhels F. Tvory. [Composition⁆, 4, 322–339.

[in Russian].

Ivanenko, V., Udod, O. & Romanets. (Eds.) (1993). Narodna trahediia. Dokumenty i materialy pro podii 1932–1933 rokiv

na Dnipropetrovshchyni. [People’s Tragedy. Documents and materials about the events of 1932–1933 in the Dnipropetrovs’k region⁆.

Dnipropetrovsk: DDU. [in Ukrainian].

Kulchytskyi, S. (2004). Opir selianstva sutsilnii kolektyvizatsii. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal. [Peasant resistance to complete

collectivization.⁆. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal. [Ukrainian Historical Journal⁆, 2, 31–50. [in Ukrainian].

Kulchytskyi, S. (2013). Ukrainskyi Holodomor: otsinka vtrat. [Ukrainian Holodomor: assessment of losses.⁆. Kraieznavstvo

[Local history⁆. 4 (85), 37–54. [in Ukrainian].

Kulchytskyi, S. (1991). Chorna borozna. Stalin i sutsilna kolektyvizatsiia na Ukraini. [The Black Furrow. Stalin and Complete

Collectivization in Ukraine⁆. Donbass. [Donbass ⁆, 1, 116–135. [in Ukrainian].

Libanova, E. (2009). Otsinka demohrafichnykh vtrat Ukrainy vnaslidok holodomoru 1932–1933 rokiv. [Assessment of

demographic losses in Ukraine as a result of the famine of 1932–1933⁆. Holodomor 1932‒1933 rokiv v Ukraini: prychyny, demohrafichni

naslidky, pravova otsinka. Mater. Mizhnar. nauk. konf. [The Holodomor of 1932–1933 in Ukraine: Causes, Demographic Consequences,

Legal Assessment. Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference⁆. Kyiv: Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia. [in Ukrainian].

Lenіn, V. (1968). Proekt prohrammy nashei partii [The draft program of our party⁆. Poln. sobr. soch. Moscow: Polytyzdat. [The

full collection is composed⁆, 4, 211 – 239[in Russian].

Lenіn, V. (1968). Chto takoe «druzia naroda» y kak oni voiuiut protiv sotsial-demokratov [What are «friends of the people» and

how do they fight against the Social Democrats⁆. Poln. sobr. soch. [The full collection is composed⁆, 1, 125–346[in Russian].

Lenіn, V. (1968). Эkonomycheskoe soderzhanye narodnychestva [he economic content of populism⁆. Poln. sobr. soch. [The

full collection is composed⁆, 1, 347–534[in Russian].

Lytvyn, V. (Ed). (2003). Holod 1932–1933 rokiv v Ukraini: prychyny ta naslidky. [The famine of 1932–1933 in Ukraine:

causes and consequences.⁆. Kyiv: Naukova dumka. [in Ukrainian].

Makhorin, H. (2017). Formy oporu ukrainskoho selianstva u chasy Holodomoru 1932‒1933 rr. [Forms of resistance of the

Ukrainian peasantry during the Holodomor of 1932–1933.⁆. Zhytomyr Vydavets FOP Yevenok O. O. [in Ukrainian].

Marks, K. (1956) ManIfest KomunIstychnoi partii [Manifesto of the Communist Party⁆. Marks K., Enhels F. Tvory.

[Compositions⁆. Moskva: Hospolitizdat, 4, 419–459. [in USSR⁆.

Mekheda, N. (2017). Istoriohrafiia sotsialno-demohrafichnykh ta moralno-psykholohichnykh naslidkiv Holodomoru 1932–

rokiv. [Historiography of the socio-demographic and moral-psychological consequences of the Holodomor of 1932–1933⁆. Materialy

Mizhnarodnoi naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii «Holodomor 1932–1933 rokiv: vtraty ukrainskoi natsii». [Materials of the International

Scientific and Practical Conference «Holodomor of 1932-1933: Losses of the Ukrainian Nation»⁆. Kyiv, 4 zhovtnia 2016 roku)_Kyiv:

Vydavets Oleh Filiuk. [in Ukrainian].

Mykhailichenko, E. & Shatalina (Eds). (1993). Kolektyvizatsiia i holod na Ukraini. 1929–1933. Zbirnyk dokumentiv i

materialiv. Druhe vydannia. [Collectivization and famine in Ukraine. 1929–1933. Collection of documents and materials. Second edition.

Kyiv: Naukova dumka. [in Ukrainian].

Nikiliev, O. (2005). Holod 1932–1933: selo v konteksti teorii i praktyky marksyzmu. [The famine of 1932–1933: the village in

the context of the theory and practice of Marxism.⁆. Hrani. [Faces ⁆, 6, 59–61. [in Ukrainian].

Nikiliev, O. (2022). Holodomor: kilkisni naslidky trahedii v interpretatsii ukrainskykh doslidnykiv. Problema poshuku istyny.

[Holodomor: quantitative consequences of the tragedy as interpreted by Ukrainian researchers. The problem of searching for truth⁆. Hrani.

[Faces⁆, 25, 6, 60–66. https://doi.org/10.15421/172270 [in Ukrainian].

Nuar, A. (2020). Vyvchennia velykoho lyvanskohohololu 1914-1918:naukovyi pidkhid (konspetk promovy). [Studying

the Great Lebanese Revolution 1914–1918: A Scientific Approach (Speech Outline)⁆. Materialy Mizhnarodnoi naukovo-praktychnoi

konferentsii «Problema ekzystatsiinoho vyboru pid chas holodomoru-henotsydu». [Materials of the International Scientific and Practical

Conference «The problem of existential choice during the golodomor-genocide»⁆. Kyiv: Vydavets Melnyk Yu. M. [in Ukrainian].

Osobystyi arkhiv avtora. [The author’s personal archive.⁆. Spohady Dovban L. A. [Memories of Dovban L. A.⁆. [In Ukrainian].

Papakin, H. (2013). «Chorna doshka»: antyselianski represii (1932–1933) [«Blackboard: Anti-peasant repressions (1932–

⁆. Kyiv: Instytut istorii Ukrainy. [in Ukrainian].

Petryshyna, O., Herasymenko, M., & Stasiuk, O. (Eds). (2021). Henotsyd ukraintsiv 1932–1933. Za materialamy dosudovykh

rozsliduvan. [Genocide of Ukrainians 1932–1933. Based on materials of pre-trial investigations⁆. Kyiv: Vyd. Marka Melnyka. [in

Ukrainian].

Podkur, R. (2005). Zbroinyi vystup yak radykalna forma oporu radianskii vladi v USRR v 1920 – na pochatku 1930-kh (za

materialamy VUChK-HPU) [Armed uprising as a radical form of resistance to Soviet power in the Ukrainian SSR in the 1920s and early

s (based on materials from the Ukrainian State Committee for the Procuracy of the GPU), 31, 90–102⁆. [in Ukrainian].

Polishchuk, T. (Ed.). (1997). Chorni zhnyva. Holod 1932–1933 rokiv u Valkivskomu ta Kolomatskomu raionakh Kharkivshchyny

(dokumenty, spohady, spysky pomerlykh). [Black Harvest. The famine of 1932–1933 in the Valkivsky and Kolomatsky districts of the

Kharkiv region (documents, memoirs, lists of the dead)⁆. Kyiv, Kharkiv, Niu-Iork, Filadelifia. Vyd-vo M. P. Kots. [in Ukrainian].

Polishchuk, T. (Ed.). (1997). Chorni zhnyva. Holod 1932–1933 rokiv u Valkivskomu ta Kolomatskomu raionakh Kharkivshchyny

(dokumenty, spohady, spysky pomerlykh). [Black Harvest. The famine of 1932–1933 in the Valkiv and Kolomatsky districts of the

Kharkiv region (documents, memoirs, lists of the dead)⁆. Kyiv, Kharkiv, Niu-Iork, Filadelifia. Vyd-vo M. P. Kots. [in Ukrainian].

Pyrih, R. (Ed). (2007). Holodomor 1932–1933 rokiv v Ukraini: dokumenty i materialy/ Uporiadn. [The Holodomor of 1932–

in Ukraine: documents and materials⁆. Pyrih R. Ya. Kyiv: Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia. [in Ukrainian].

Reva, I. (2007). Po toi bik sebe: sotsialno-psykholohchni ta kulturni naslidky Holodooru i stalinskykh represii. [Beyond

Yourself: The Socio-Psychological and Cultural Consequences of the Holodomor and Stalinist Repressions⁆.Dnipropetrovsk, Vyd-vo

«Svidler A. L.». [in Ukrainian].

Romanets, N. (2014). Represyvna polityka Radianskoi vlady v ukrainskomu seli (1925–1939). [The repressive policy of the

Soviet government in the Ukrainian countryside (1925–1939))⁆ Kryvyi Rih: Vyd. R. A. Kozlov. [in Ukrainian].

Romanets, N. (2018). Selianstvo Dnipropetrovshchyny v umovakh stalinskoi revoliutsii «zghory»: nastroi, povedinka, opir

sotsialistychnii modernizatsii ahrarnoho sektora (1928–1933). [Peasantry of Dnipropetrovs’k region under the conditions of Stalin’s

revolution «from above»: attitudes, behavior, resistance to socialist modernization of the agricultural sector (1928–1933)⁆.Trahichne

mynule. [The Tragic Past⁆, 1. Dnipro: Monoloh. [in Ukrainian].

Rozsekrechena pamiat: Holod 1932–1933 rokiv v Ukraini v dokumentakh HPU-NKVD. [Declassified Memory: The Famine

of 1932–1933 in Ukraine in GPU-NKVD Documents⁆ Declassified Memory: The Famine of 1932–1933 in Ukraine in GPU-NKVD

Documents (5theds). Kyiv: Stylos. [in Ukrainian⁆.

Serhiichuk H. (2017).Vtraty ukrainskykh selian vtikachiv za kordon u 1932–1933 rokakh. [Losses of Ukrainian peasants fleeing

abroad in 1932–1933⁆. Materialy Mizhnarodnoi naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii «Holodomor 1932–1933 rokiv: vtraty ukrainskoi

natsii». [Materials of the International Scientific and Practical Conference «Holodomor 1932–1933: Losses of the Ukrainian Nation»⁆.

Kyiv: Vydavnytstvo Oleh Fyliuk. [in Ukrainian].

Stalin, Y. (1949). К voprosam ahrarnoi polіtyky v SSSR[On issues of agrarian policy in the USSR⁆. Sochynenyia. [Compositions⁆,

, 149–165. [in Russian].

Stalin, Y. (1949).Ytohy pervoi piatyletky [Results of the first five-year plan⁆. Sochynenyia [Compositions⁆, 13, 190–205. [in

Russian].

Stasiuk, O. (2021). Stanovlennia, formuvannia, diialnist totalitarnoi instytutsii upovnovazhenykh v USRR v roky Holodomoruhenotsydu.

[The emergence, formation, and activities of the totalitarian institution of plenipotentiaries in the Ukrainian SSR during the

Holodomor-genocide⁆. Pereiaslav: Dombrovska Ya. M. [in Ukrainian].

Shchur Yu. (2023). Radianske «upokorennia holodom» ta problema ukrainskoho vyzvolnoho rukhu na Zaporizhzhi. [Soviet

«subjugation by hunger» and the problem of the Ukrainian liberation movement in Zaporizhia⁆. Ukrainskyi selianyn. [Ukrainian peasant⁆,

, 90–98 DOI: 10.31651/2413-8142-2023-29-Shchur [in Ukrainian].

Trahedyia sovetskoi derevni. Kollektyvyzatsyia y raskulachyvanye. Dokumenty i materyaly. 1927–1939. [The tragedy of the

Soviet village. Collectivization and disenfranchisement. Documents and materials. 1927–1939. (2000). Moskva, 2. [in Russian].

Tsentralnyi derzhavnyi arkhiv vyshchykh orhaniv vlady i upravlinnia Ukrainy.

Tsentralnyi derzhavnyi arkhiv hromadskykh obiednan Ukrainy.

Vasyliev V. Yu. (2005). Selianskyi opir kolektyvizatsii v Ukraini (1930-ti rr.). [Peasant resistance to collectivization in Ukraine

(1930s)⁆. Istoriia Ukrainy. Malovidomi imena, podii, fakty. [History of Ukraine. Little-known names, events, facts.⁆, 31, 140–150. [in

Ukrainian].

Veselova, O. & Nikiliev O. (Eds). (2009). Pam’iat narodu: henotsyd v Ukraini holodom 1932–1933 rokiv. Svidchennia.

[Memory of the People: Genocide in Ukraine by the Famine of 1932–1933. Testimony⁆. Uporiadnyky: O. Veselova, O. Nikiliev.

Kyiv: «KALYTA». [in Ukrainian].

Vodotyka, S. (2024.). Vplyv oporu selianstva chasiv sutsilnoi kolektyvizatsii i Holodomoru na transformatsiiu bilshovytskoho

proektu pobudovy komunizmu. [The impact of peasant resistance during the times of complete collectivization and the Holodomor on

the transformation of the Bolshevik project of building communism ⁆. Pivdennyi arkhiv (istorychni nauky). [Southern Archive (historical

sciences)⁆, 47, 17–24. [in Ukrainian]. DOI https://doi.org/10.32999/ksu2786-5118/2024-47-3

Vodotyka, S., & Savenok, L. (2023). Ukrainske selo naperedodni stalinskoi kolektyvizatsii: chy isnuvala alternatyva

istorychnoho postupu. [Ukrainian village on the eve of Stalin’s collectivization: was there an alternative to historical progress?⁆. Pivdennyi

arkhiv (istorychni nauky). [Southern Archive (historical sciences)⁆, 42, 17–24. DOI https://doi.org/10.32999/ksu2786-5118/2023-42-3[in

Ukrainian].

Yatsuk, P. (1999). Portret temriavy. Svidchennia, dokumenty i materialy. [Portrait of Darkness. Testimonies, Documents and

Materials⁆, 1. Kyiv-Niu-Iork: Vyd. M. P. Kots. [in Ukrainian].